“Why did Jimmy Smits leave NYPD Blue?” is an excellent question considering the importance of Bobby Simone and Smits’ award-winning performance as the character. NYPD Blue is ranked high among the best cop shows of all time, and its attention to detail, gritty storytelling, and across-the-board top-notch performances have made it stand out among a packed field of police procedurals. Its mature themes have kept it in the pop culture consciousness long after it ended in 2005.