Emily Prentiss’ Criminal Minds: Evolution season 2’s arc will have ties to her past, showrunner Gwen Sigan reveals. Paget Brewster may not be an original cast member of the hit CBS police procedural, but she is part of the core ensemble that is widely regarded as the best roster of profilers on the show. Starting out as a member of the team, Prentiss was eventually promoted to BAU chief after Aaron Hotchner’s unexpected departure from Criminal Minds. Now, she continues to spearhead the FBI’s special unit as they delve into the Gold Star mystery in Criminal Minds: Evolution season 2.